Opportunistic? Or Insensitive Jerks?

We all remember where we were on September 11th, 2001. My family and I were all getting ready to head out of the 9-11 ohouse, the television filling in as background noise for the chaos of my family’s morning routine, when all of the sudden, BREAKING NEWS was shining bright across the screen. My mother held me tight as we watched the footage of Flight 175 crash into one of the Twin Towers, footage that still evokes fear and sadness whenever I see it. Thirteen years later, I woke up this morning to get ready for class and scrolled through my Instagram feed to find a plethora of memorial pictures with the caption reading “#NeverForget.”

On AdWeek.com today, there is an article featured by AdFreak titled, “This Guy’s Replies to 9/11 Brand Tweets Sum Up Everything That’s Wrong With 9/11 Brand Tweets.” At first I thought, what is so wrong with brands expressing grief and memorial tributes to something that so deeply impacted all Americans? But then I read the tweets he was responding to, and I got a little disgusted. The one that bothered me the most was by Tee Major (@Tee_Major) reading “’Never Forget’ September 11 2014 [ONE DAY ONLY] 20% OFF all digital weight training, Screen Shot 2014-09-11 at 1.29.44 PMbodyweight training…” I don’t need to finish the rest of the tweet because it’s very clear what he was advertising. Some brands are using this day of remembrance and sorrow as chances to promote and advertise their brands and products because the “NeverForget” hashtag is so prominent in the Twitter-world today.

The man that was replying to the tweets, Mike Monteiro, has been spending the day responding to different companies. For example, in response to Tee Major, he wrote, “I wanna get ripped and kick terrorist ass, @Tee_Major!” In some cases, I think he went too far, such as in response to Applebee’s simple tweet: “We will never forget,” attached with a picture, Monteiro responded, “Thank you @Applebees. When we pulled Mother’s body out of the wreckage we dragged it to Applebees. And you guys gave us free sodas.” In my opinion, I think Monteiro took the Applebees tweet too far, as Applebees did not use a hashtag, did not promote themselves or any type of special discount, nor did they offer free sodas.

It’s a rather obvious statement that brands and companies are not people, but brands and companies are run by people. Is it wrong for companies to comment on historical events that define us as a country, or should they keep their tweets to themselves? At what point does it become inappropriate for companies to use popular social media hashtags as advertisement (for example, if it’s #LaborDay, would it be wrong for Sears to use that hashtag to promote their Labor Day weekend sale?)

http://www.adweek.com/adfreak/guys-replies-911-brand-tweets-sum-everything-thats-wrong-911-brand-tweets-160060

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Opportunistic? Or Insensitive Jerks?

  1. I know a lot of brands feel obligated to post about events like 9/11. When in the end, it really hurts their brand image. Today, the toy company Build-a-Bear tweeted a picture of their army-themed teddy bear, attached with a memorial statement. The tweet was taken down within fifteen minutes because people were so offended by using the event to sell toys.

    Like

  2. In this country, I just have the expectation that everything is fair game for advertising. People will try to make money off of anything. I do not think that it is a terrible thing, because I understand that everyone needs to make money. However, it can definitely get annoying, and in some cases, offensive. This is one of the more classless attempts at advertising that I have seen, and I am sure that if someone close to me had died in 9/11 I would be pretty upset about it. So basically, I do not think that using 9/11 as an advertising opportunity is ethical at all, but I am not at all surprised that someone is trying to do it.

    Like

  3. I agree that the tweet you featured here is entirely inappropriate, as is the reply to the tweet, but in this day and age people will post garbage (pardon my french) on twitter. I believe the vast majority of tweets are expressions of personal opinion that give insight into the personality of a person or entity. So, when companies use events with historical significance such as 9/11 or Labor Day to promote something with no relevance it goes to show the exploitative nature of the said company. Granted, if a store is having a labor day sale, they might just be doing so to even out the competition, but 9/11 sales are entirely misappropriated. There is no competitive aspect in that regard, so why take a risk of offending customers?

    Like

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s