Jailed for a Bad Joke

I have a quick story for you. Once upon a time, in a land far far way, my parents were not on Facebook. It was 2009, and life was simple and the possibilities were endless. I could post  whatever raunchy comment or profane inside joke I wanted, with no consequences. But all good things must come to an end, and so it did one day when I got a call from my dad about a particularly heinous post a fellow high school freshman put on my wall. I was efficiently scolded and grounded, but I learned my lesson: be careful what you post on Facebook. Fortunately, I was not put in jail, which was one 18-year-old Texan’s punishment.

Justin Carter, in a sarcastic online exchange between friends (over an online video game, apparently), made the grossly insensitive comment: “”I’m fucked in the head alright, I think I’ma SHOOT UP A KINDERGARTEN.” In the wake of tragedies like Sandy Hook, this was obviously not the most tasteful comment. Had he been a Walters boy, he would have had a tear-inducing scolding, with orders to take the comment down and make an apology. However, when (bizarrely) a Canadian who saw the comment reported it as a threat, Carter was arrested and sent to Comal County jail, where he spent four months (and reportedly was attacked by inmates several times).

Now, Carter faces up to 10 years in prison, even though searches of his home showed nothing that might indicate his comment was nothing more than an idiotic attempt at being funny. His comments, captured on a screenshot, have been taken completely out of context, without the original message to prove that he was not serious. He is now being charged as a terrorist, and his life is effectively ruined.

This is the second time I’ve used this blog to be a “defender of the people,” having previously written about Justine Sacco’s death- by-Tweet. To clarify, I have no personal affection for these people, and honestly, probably wouldn’t have much to do with a person that would make Sandy Hook jokes on Facebook. However, I think we should think twice before we throw someone’s life away for a Facebook comment. Had he made the comment verbally to his friends, he would not have been branded a terrorist. However, Facebook is now becoming dangerously intertwined with reality, in a confusing way. We need to use common sense and discretion when treating Facebook as if it is reality.
Malislow, C. 2014, February 14. Young man’s violent threat on Facebook lands him in jail. Houston Press. Retrieved February 14, 2014 from http://www.houstonpress.com/2014-02-13/news/justin-carter-facebook/.

2 thoughts on “Jailed for a Bad Joke

  1. I think accountability is something our generation forgets about. I have friends who post all sorts of inappropriate things, from pictures of them drinking underage to ridiculous comments that call their character into question. They don’t realize that everything on their social media will be looked at- by professors they ask for recommendation letters from and future employers when they are trying to narrow down applicants from the large number of possibilities that apply. While I think this situation was an overreaction, I also think we need to educate more on how nothing online is a secret.


  2. I think what he did was obviously idiotic, and a lot of people do not think before they post. But really a terrorist? We have way more problems in this world then putting this guy in jail for 4 months and labeling him a terrorist. I think the shame and hatred of the internet is enough. Social media brings out the stupid in a lot of people, it reminds me of the girl who posted a picture of her Halloween costume of a victim of the Boston massacre. She took it to a whole new level, but her family was threatened by tons of people online. That was obviously unnecessary, but I think she should have been put in jail not this guy.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s